ETFs vs Stocks: Which Investment is Right for Me?

One of the best ways to build wealth and save for retirement is to invest in the stock market–but it’s critical to invest wisely. No matter how much you can afford to invest, there’s always a chance of losing more than you gain if you choose the wrong stocks. 

Whether you’re an experienced investor or investing for the first time, you may be faced with the decision of what kind of investment approach is right for you. Many investors fall into one of two groups: those who purchase individual stocks and those who invest in funds, such as exchange-traded funds (ETFs). Thanks to technology, investing in these financial assets has never been easier.  

Both investments can be excellent choices, but they cater to different types of investors. It’s a big decision, so if you’re unsure whether to invest in stocks or ETFs, keep this in mind: You want a strategy that reduces your risk, while also producing returns that outperform the market. 

This article hopes to give you a clear overview of two very popular financial assets by discussing the key similarities and differences between them, as well as the pros and cons of each, so that you can understand what you’re investing in, make better investment decisions, and get closer to your personal goal of financial independence. 

But first, what are stocks and ETFs?

The difference between buying a stock and buying an ETF is comparable to the difference between buying one apple and buying a whole basket of groceries. Let’s say you buy a stock in the company Apple – this means you are investing in one individual company. When the stock price of Apple rises or falls, so does the value of your investment. 

ETFs, on the other hand, are like baskets containing a collection of assets, such as stocks, bonds, currencies, or commodities (such as gold bars). This allows you to invest in a variety of assets all in one go, instead of trying to select individual “winners” or “losers”.  This diversification of investment reduces the risk of major losses, which makes them ideal for long-term investors. ETFs are similar to index funds, which track the performance of a market, but unlike other funds, you can trade them like stocks and still reap the benefits of diversification. 

Similarities between stocks and ETFs:

  • They both trade on a stock exchange. This means they have a lot of liquidity and transparency, and are often easy to buy and sell because they are widely available and traded in large volumes throughout the day. 
  • They can both provide you with a diverse range of investing possibilities. Both, for example, can be used to invest in a variety of industries, businesses of all sizes, global marketplaces, and more. 
  • They are bought and sold at the price that appears at the moment of purchase. That means you can invest in an ETF or stock with ease and speed while the stock market is open, knowing exactly what you’re getting and for how much. 
  • Possibility of dividends. Lots of companies pay dividends to shareholders on a regular basis, which constitute a portion of the company’s profits. Additionally, ETFs may receive dividends from the stocks they hold, which are then distributed to the ETF shareholders. 
  • Transaction fees. Both are easily traded on exchanges and are widely available through online brokerages. These platforms are also increasingly lowering their commission rates– removing barriers for individual investors wishing to include stocks and ETFs in their portfolios. 

Now let’s consider six key differences:

  1. Risk vs potential return:  

Stocks: Individual stocks are a high-risk investment due to the potential price swings and increased probability of large losses when things don’t go well for the company. That said, if you choose the right company, a stock can also generate higher gains. 

ETFs: ETFs have significant built-in diversification because they invest in dozens or even hundreds of companies. This means that one stock’s poor performance may be balanced out by the other, higher-performing stocks. As a result, they are generally safer than buying individual stocks, because, while one company’s fortunes may decline, the worth of a group of companies is less likely to be as volatile.  

However, there is a chance this could limit potential returns, as when you buy a broad basket of stocks, you’re buying both losers and winners, so the end result averages out.  

2. Diversification:  

Stocks: In order to gain meaningful diversification with stocks, you have to separately buy shares in a variety of different companies, which can be costly. 

ETFs: A single share of an ETF is a combination of several different investments. As a result, diversifying your portfolio with ETFs will be less expensive than it would be if you bought the same stocks separately. 

3. Market exposure: 

Stocks: Stocks allow you to concentrate your money on a single firm you believe in, such as one that is well-managed or innovative. 

ETFs: As we know, there are many different types of ETFs and they offer investors an easy way to get broad exposure to different markets. Unlike stocks, however, you can’t use an ETF to focus on a single firm. 

4. Growth:  

Stocks: Growth stocks exhibit above-average revenue and earnings growth potential. They also see faster growth in revenue and income than their peers. However, you’ll need to identify as many future winners as possible while avoiding losers, so there is always higher risk of losses. 

ETFs: They offer stability thanks to their diversification. Long-term investing is one of the best ways to make money in the stock market. Growth ETFs, for example, are designed to gain higher-than-average growth rates, allowing you to grow your money faster. 

5. Research, time and effort: 

Stocks: If you invest in stocks, you’ll need to perform all of your own research and trading. Some investors may like it, while others will find it too time consuming or complicated. 

ETFs: ETFs are professionally managed to achieve the goals of the fund. All the work of researching, buying, and selling individual stocks is done for you. However, you still need to decide which ETFs to purchase, so some study is essential. 

6. Control of Investments:  

Stocks: If you invest in stocks, you decide exactly where your money is going, and which companies you’re investing in. Some investors like having this control, but others may find it too hard or too time consuming.  

ETFs: As stated, ETFs are professionally managed, so the work of researching, buying, and selling for an optimized outcome is done for you. This can be convenient for people who don’t have the time to do research, or aren’t experienced enough to control their own investments. 

So, which is the best option for you?

For investors who are willing to take on additional risk, stocks may provide a superior return. Individual stock purchases also allow you to focus your investments on companies that you value and believe in.  

Stocks also tend to benefit investors who are prepared to devote the time and effort necessary to learn about specific stocks and the factors that may influence performance in some way. 

ETFs, on the other hand, can help investors avoid volatility and reduce risk by allowing them to diversify and obtain easier access to various sectors and broader markets.  

It’s worth noting that for some investors–including beginners and less researched investors–ETFs make more sense because many investors don’t know how to beat the market. ETFs are also an appealing choice for long-term investors due to having a lower expense ratio than other funds while generating higher returns when held for the long run. For these investors, it’s less about ‘timing the market’ and more about ‘time in the market’. 

In any case, it’s important to remember that you don’t have to choose just one. In fact, a portfolio containing stocks, ETFs, and other assets may be the key to a masterfully diversified investing strategy for many investors. 

Are you interested in learning more about how you can optimize your portfolio for the best results?

Get in touch with artyarty is an AI Robo-advisor that can offer you detailed portfolio recommendations for a more optimised portfolio, as well as instructions on how to implement them. We passionately believe in the democratization of the financial market and want to give individuals access to the same investment strategies that the bigger players are using. Our longer-term investment philosophy, combined with advanced artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) for an optimised portfolio, offers you the chance to achieve better allocations and higher returns with personalized investment portfolio advice. arty is here to help you make better investment decisions and achieve your goal of financial independence.

Access for free ETF Quant portfolios

arty ETF portfolios are based on AI